The Zodiac Killer’s cryptic messages weren’t just taunts to police — they were a twisted throwback to his first victim, according to an independent investigator who says he’s cracked the code and uncovered new evidence suggesting the infamous serial killer began his career 23 years earlier with the California murder of Elizabeth Short, also known as the Black Dahlia.
Alex Baber, co-founder of Cold Case Consultants of America, said that after nine months of work, he cracked a double-layered encryption that involved transposition and substitution in a 2 by 7 grid.
“Currently, for the first time in history, LAPD detectives approached the family of a suspect to obtain DNA,” he told Fox News Digital in an interview on the sidelines of the Hamptons Whodunit event in East Hampton over the weekend. “That’s never happened for the Black Dahlia case… we got a pretty good feeling that we’re sitting in the right seat.”
The Los Angeles Police Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment. An FBI spokesperson declined to weigh in.
TED BUNDY UNMASKED IN DECADES-OLD TEEN MURDER AS COLD CASE FINALLY SOLVED BY DNA: REPORT
Baber’s finding, that the Zodiac’s “Z13” cipher depicts the name of a prime suspect in the 1947 Black Dahlia murder, was first revealed in the Daily Mail, and he presented them publicly Saturday at the East Hampton Library.
With help from a proprietary artificial intelligence software and self-taught knowledge of cryptography, he said the 13-character message is decoded to read “Marvin Merrill.” After further digging into social security records, he said he discovered that’s an alias for Marvin Margolis, who he said dated Short in the 1940s and had been on the LAPD’s suspect list after her murder and dismemberment. His AI software flagged the connection between the two cases, he added.
Once he’d developed Margolis as a potential suspect, he said he went to visit his surviving son, who showed him a handwriting sample, which Baber said he suspected was a match to Zodiac both in terms of the handwriting and linguistically.
When Baber revealed his findings to the son, he recounted the following reaction:
“He immediately turned white, his hands started shaking and he reached across the table — when he grabbed my hand,” Baber said. “First time I’ve ever had an interview where they’ve initiated physical contact with me, and at that point, he says, ‘We’re gonna be OK.'”
The son provided writing samples showing both Zodiac and Margolis made the same phonetic spelling errors, Baber said.
“I said, ‘I hate to blow your mind, but he’s also suspect on record not from my agency but from the grand jury inquest with the original files for LAPD in 1947 of Elizabeth Short’s homicide,'” Baber recalled.
“He said, ‘Elizabeth? Well, let me show you something,'” Baber continued.
After flipping through his phone, he produced a haunting sketch, labeled “Elizabeth” across the bottom.
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
“The first thing I said is, ‘Holy s—,'” Baber said.
He provided images of a sketch Margolis drew 46 years after Short’s death, which he says showed additional detail when viewed in person — indentations on the page from a pencil tip used to add texture to the inked drawing. The alarming part about those features is that they coincide with injuries sustained by Short, he said, and that an impression of the word “Zodiac” is hidden within a black background on the bottom right of the image.
SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER
After Baber cracked the code, he said he shared it with the FBI and had it peer-reviewed by other experts, including one he described as a former National Security Agency codebreaker.
That one, he said, reverse engineered his decryption and realized that the key to the cipher was far simpler: the Black Dahlia victim’s first name, Elizabeth.
“Elizabeth was the key to solving the Z13,” he said. He said her name generates a numerical sequence used to rearrange the cipher.
Another notable connection Baber said he found was between Margolis and a close friend who specialized in encryption during World War II.
LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST
“His roommate Bill Robinson, who lived with him when he lived with Elizabeth Short, was actually one of the hand-picked cryptographers in World War II by General MacArthur,” he said.
Margolis lived with Robinson in Los Angeles at the time of Short’s murder, according to police records from the investigation Baber obtained and shared with his findings. The records also show Margolis was one of 22 persons of interest back in 1951.
John Kelly, a criminal profiler and psychoanalyst who has been following the case for years, told Fox News Digital he reviewed Baber’s materials and found his findings “have legs.”
LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? FIND MORE ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
“This person of interest has had numerous careers and failed at all,” Kelly told Fox News Digital.
But one that stood out was his service as a medic in the Pacific during World War II.
“The career field that produces the most serial killers is the medical field,” he said, pointing toward Dr. Harold Shipman, who killed more than 200 of his own patients, and nurse Charles Cullen, who killed dozens of his own.
Five of the 22 early suspects in Short’s murder were also doctors, the records show.
“In my opinion, this guy fits like a glove,” Kelly said.
