Allow me to start things off by wishing the iconic Sopranos episode, “Pine Barrens,” a very happy 25th birthday.
On May 6, 2001, Chrissy and Paulie went from being a couple of made men to “just two a–holes stranded in the woods.”
Many people cite the season three masterpiece as their all-time favorite Sopranos episode, but I’ve always found it to be a bit overrated.
So, what better way to celebrate one of the most revered hours of television ever than to go through what are, in my humble opinion, four of the most overrated TV episodes of all time.
‘LOST’ LEADS NOSTALGIA TV POPULARITY FOR AUDIENCES SEEKING ‘INNOCENT TIME’: EXPERTS
The term “overrated” is subjective, obviously, and every episode on this list is an episode I really enjoy from some of my favorite TV shows ever, but they are also episodes that I think get held up on a pedestal a bit more than they should.
I’ll stop with the rambling so we can get this show on the road.
One thing that almost all of the episodes have on this list is that they are very self-contained, and maybe it’s just a personal preference, but I’m not a huge fan of “bottle episodes.”
Comedy shows in and of themselves rarely have overarching plots, though The Office certainly has plenty of story arc to it.
“Dinner Party” is a departure from many of the plot-focused episodes in the earlier seasons of the show, and it focuses entirely on the characters.
It works, and it’s an enjoyable slice of television, but I often hear people call this their favorite episode of The Office, and that’s likely because of one thing: the pervasiveness of “meme culture.”
As far as memes go, “Dinner Party” is one of the strongest of a show that is chock-full of meme-worthy episodes.
From “snip snap” to the tiny TV, this episode has about as many GIFs to its name as any half-hour of network television, but it almost feels like the quotes are more memorable than the episode as a whole.
If reading all that made you mad, you might want to turn back now, because it gets a lot worse from here.
Oh, boy! I can feel the flames from the angry mob rising as I type.
One thing Game of Thrones did with aplomb, at least in the earlier seasons, was set up an entire season’s worth of events for one big payoff.
Season one had the death of Ned Stark come completely out of left field after he discovered the truth about the Lannister family, while season two built up the battle at King’s Landing in Blackwater.
By the time season three rolls around, it feels like there needs to be one hell of a payoff to top the first two penultimate episodes of their respective seasons.
Before I even started watching Game of Thrones, people who had already finished the series warned me about “Rains of Castamere.”
I wasn’t given any spoilers, but I was told this was the episode that changed everything, and that I’ll never be the same after this hour of television.
‘SEINFELD’ STAR SPARKS VIRAL AIRPLANE TREND, DECLARES HIMSELF ‘ORIGINAL RAWDOGGER’
When Ned Stark gets his head lopped off in season one’s “Baelor,” I remember being shocked, while also thinking, “Man! I can’t wait to see what ‘Rains of Castamere’ has in store.”
And, to be honest, maybe I’m a victim of something being overhyped and underdelivering, but the deaths of Robb and Catelyn Stark, along with Robb’s wife and unborn child, just didn’t have the same payoff.
Killing off a man who was essentially the main character, by most fantasy trope standards, in the first season was bold and subverted expectations, but it made any twist afterwards feel secondary by comparison.
I know George R.R. Martin and the producers didn’t write all of these stories with that in mind, but it definitely tamped down a lot of the excitement I had going into “Rains of Castamere.”
It might be unfair to dock this episode for the hype being heaped onto it, and maybe I missed out on the thrill of seeing it fresh for the first time, but “Rains of Castamere” is far from the best episode of Game of Thrones, despite what many may say.
One thing Seinfeld did throughout its run is tackle taboo topics while making them palatable for network television audiences, and “The Contest” might be the best example of this.
In this season-four fan favorite, Jerry, Elaine, George and Kramer all see who can last the longest without “treating their body like an amusement park,” if you catch my drift.
The episode is full of hilarious sight gags and iconic lines, but much like with “Dinner Party,” the quotes have almost taken on a life of their own.
For example, I bet you forgot the B-plot of this episode involved Elaine meeting JFK Jr.
Either way, the episode won an insane amount of awards for its clever writing and it is cited by numerous publications as one of the best episodes in the history of television, and that’s where the problems lie for me.
It’s a great episode, a classic, even. But I have a hard time calling this “one of the best episodes of television ever.”
It’s not even the best episode of Seinfeld from season four, as classics like “The Outing” and “The Junior Mint” are equally iconic without all the pomp and circumstance.
Maybe it’s the hipster contrarian in me, but any time something gets overly lauded for its “clever writing,” it’s an instant turnoff.
You can take your Primetime Emmy and stick it where the sun don’t shine!
It was the entire reason for writing this article, so you knew it was going to end up on here.
I can’t think of a more overrated hour of television than “Pine Barrens.”
To be fair, it’s an intensely enjoyable episode, but this season-three one-off ends up right at the top of every Sopranos fans’ “best of” list, and I just don’t see it.
People talk about the humor from “Pine Barrens” as if it’s something unique to this episode, but every episode of the show is so laugh-out-loud funny that I often pitch The Sopranos as a black comedy masquerading as a mob drama.
All that is to say, the humor present in “Pine Barrens” doesn’t exactly set it apart from the rest of the heap.
Much like “Dinner Party,” “Pine Barrens” is a true bottle episode, and really doesn’t do too much to advance the plot in season three outside of Tony’s deteriorating relationship with his goomar, Gloria.
ZERO BS. JUST DAKICH. TAKE THE DON’T @ ME PODCAST ON THE ROAD. DOWNLOAD NOW!
The entire episode revolves around Chrissy and Paulie getting lost in the woods of southern New Jersey, and needing to survive until help arrives.
The premise and execution are fantastic, and the episode is admittedly humorous, but as is the case with all the other entries on this list, the humor and quotes have taken on a life of their own.
Yes, “he was an interior decorator” is a funny line the first 100 times you hear it, but the Sopranos community is guilty of running that whole exchange into the ground.
“Pine Barrens” is a great episode to throw on when you want some “comfort food,” but there are far better episodes of the show, and I’ve never understood the hype it has gotten over the last quarter century.
